Are old Reader's Digest Magazines worth anything?

For collectors, the allure of an item is often tied to its rarity, historical significance, or enduring cultural impact. Unfortunately for Reader's Digest magazine enthusiasts, the publication doesn't check many of those boxes when it comes to being a valuable collectible.

A Common Misconception

Some might assume that because Reader's Digest was once a popular and widely circulated magazine, older issues would have "collector" value today. The short answer? WRONG! No, they don’t—with the possible exception of the very first issue. Even in pristine, "like new" condition, Reader's Digest magazines have little, if any, market value.

Overproduction: The Supply Is Too High

The primary reason Reader's Digest magazines aren’t valuable is simple: they were mass-produced in high numbers over a long period of time. There’s no shortage of available copies, even in "good" condition. As a result, the supply far outweighs any collector demand, making these magazines almost worthless as collectibles. On the iGuide Demand Scale—where A+ indicates the most sought-after items—Reader's Digest magazines score a dismal D, indicating that demand is practically non-existent.

The First Issue Exception

As mentioned, the first issue of Reader's Digest holds marginally more value, but even that exception comes with a caveat. First editions or rare issues might be more valuable than later ones, but the market is limited. You might find a buyer willing to pay a bit more for the inaugural issue, but it won’t fetch the kind of prices that, say, a first-edition comic book or vintage baseball card might.

---

If you have what you think may be a rare magazine, it would be wise to get a free iGuide Appraisal Report

---

Charities and Second-Hand Stores Won’t Take Them

If you're hoping to offload your collection to a charity or second-hand store, you might be disappointed. Organizations like Goodwill don’t typically accept Reader's Digest magazines due to lack of demand. In many cases, even if they did accept them, the magazines would sit unsold on shelves. The market for reselling them simply isn’t there.

A Collectible of the Past

Ultimately, while Reader's Digest had its moment of cultural relevance, that hasn't translated into lasting collectible value. The oversaturation of copies and the lack of significant demand all contribute to the magazine’s low standing in the collectible world. For most collectors, Reader's Digest is little more than a curiosity of a bygone era—an item whose marketability has long since faded away.

Summary

If you’re sitting on a stack of old Reader's Digest magazines hoping for a financial windfall, it’s safe to say that their value is negligible. Aside from the slim possibility of owning a rare or first edition, these magazines are better suited for recycling than for any serious collector's shelf.